Phil 020E (040) 2005-2006
Introduction to Philosophy

Second Essay Assignment

Assignment: Answer one of the following questions.  Your essay should draw upon two contrasting readings that we have done.  Any of the readings from the “Knowledge” and “Metaphysics” units that we’ve covered are acceptable for this assignment.  Do not, however, use any readings from the “God” unit.

1.	Is there anything of which we can be certain?  Argue for your position, making specific reference to two philosophers we’ve read who would disagree about this.

2.	Can an idealist or a materialist (choose one) effectively respond to Descartes’ argument for the distinction between mind and body?  Explain and defend your view.

3.	Rationalists and empiricists believe that our knowledge comes about in two strikingly different ways.  Give an account of these two positions.  What is the ultimate source of knowledge?  Defend your view.

Due: To be submitted electronically in rich text format to www.turnitin.com by 10:30 a.m. on Thursday, January 12, 2006.  

Length: 4-5 pages, i.e. approximately 1000-1250 words.

Marking: The essays will be marked for care and accuracy of exposition, clarity of thinking and writing, and cogency of argument.  This is not a “research” essay.  Please do not use any secondary texts, including internet resources.  However, the primary sources that you use should be cited responsibly and in a consistent manner.  Failure to consistently follow a standard citation practice will result in a penalty of .5 (out of 10).