I. INEQUALITY & DEVELOPMENT
What poverty looks like today. Seeking to help in what
we call the "development" of other societies, we often intervene without
realizing the depth of our own commitment to our particular vision of a
good life. Do we really oppose poverty? Inequality? If we were going to,
how would we? Mead, Rebecca
2003 "Dressing for
Lula." The New Yorker
(March 17): 82-84, 86-8, 91. [7pp
Silverman, Debora
1986 Selection from
the "Preface"; "Introduction". From her: Selling
Culture: Bloomingdale's, Diana Vreeland, and the New Aristocracy of Taste
in Reagan's America. Pp. ix-xiii, & 3-5, 8-20. [16
Isbister, John
1998 Chapter 2: "A
World of Poverty." From his: Promises
Not Kept: The Betrayal of Social Change in the Third World.(4th
edn.) Pp. 7-31. [25
Robbins, Richard H.
2001 "Why Don 't Poor
Countries Modernize and Develop in the Same Way as Wealthier Countries?"
& "The Case of Brazil". From his: Cultural
Anthropology: A Problem-Based Approach. (3rd edn.) Pp. 52-56.
[5
Olivera,
Marcela & Jorge Viana
2003 "Winning the
Water War." Human Rights Dialogue
2: 9. (but read it on the web) [2
Background and
code for reading Max-Neef
Max-Neef, Manfred
1982 Chapters
6 & 7: "Peasants Get Together" & "In a World of Our Own." From
his: From the Outside Looking In: Experiences
in Barefoot Economics (Uppsala: Dag Hammarskjold Foundation).
Pp. 98-112. [15
Carter, Sarah
1995
"'We Must Farm to Enable Us to Live': The Plains Cree and Agriculture to
1900." From: The
Canadian Experience (2nd edn) (R. Bruce
Morrison & C. Roderick Wilson, eds.). Pp. 444-70. [27
BRODY, Hugh
1981 Chapter 15 "A
Hearing". From his: Maps and Dreams:
Indians and the British Columbia Frontier.
Pp.
256-270. [15
The setting
for this research was preparation of information for the major government
study of the human and environmental impact of a potential Alaska Highway
gas pipeline. This chapter reports on the public hearing held in one of
the communities of Beaver Indians for whom Brody was working. It's a classic
description of the failure of cross-cultural communication: not knowing
you're not listening.
II. WHAT IS AN ECONOMY?
Mode
of production. Production & reproduction. Foraging, horticulture,
intensive agriculture, peasantry, commercial agriculture.
State & civilization. Class. Reciprocity, redistribution, markets.
Types of leadership & control structures.
Schultz, Emily & Robt. Lavenda
2001 Chapter 10 "Making
a Living". From their: Cultural
Anthropology (5th edn.) Pp. 206-230.
[24
Meillassoux
on Foraging as a Mode of Production [2
Two Quotes
on Sharing & Reciprocity [2
Clastres
on The Duty to Speak & the Power of not Listening.
[2
Polanyi
on Market Economy & Worldview [2
BRODY, Hugh
1981 "Introduction
1988", "Preface", and Chapters 1-6, 8-9, 12, 14, 16 (skim
the rest). Pp. ix-xxv, 1-102, 115-135, 190-213, 230-255,
271-283. [190+
Especially for Canadians, this is
a very rich book. It's an exemplary discussion of the situation of one
First Nation: a thoughtfully put-together account by an outsider. There
are different kinds of understanding & different kinds of presentation.
How are they related? The nature of a mixed economy based on foraging.
Their maps & our maps, their dreams & ours. What is a frontier?
Whose
is it?
SCHIEFFELIN, Edward L.
1976 Selection of
the "Introduction" to his The Sorrow of the Lonely
and the Burning of the Dancers, pp. 1-5. [5
A wider sense of reciprocity: reading
beyond economy.
III. MORE SOCIAL FACTS:
SOCIAL
STRUCTURE, KINSHIP, COMMUNITY
Classes include: Social relations
are always organized, but in accord with different principles in different
places: these principles come to be what "makes sense" to the populace,
their sense of what's appropriate. Social groups & social
categories. Kinship as a key example. Economic, political, and
cultural power.
Kinship
and Marriage: Concepts and Jargon [2
Robbins, Richard H.
2001 Ch. 5:
"Patterns of Family Relations." From his: Cultural
Anthropology: A Problem-Based Approach. (3rd edn.) Pp. 138-67.
[30
SCHIEFFELIN, E.L.
1976 Chapters 1, 2, 3 of
The
Sorrow of the Lonely and the Burning of the Dancers.
[70
We'll discuss the whole book later.
For now, the areas of interest are the nature of communities in Bosavi,
relations between them, & the nature & place of clans in social
life. Note that Kaluli society is egalitarian (critically: except for gender).
CARLSEN, Robert S.
1997 The
War for the Heart and Soul of a Highland Maya Town.
[180
Read it all.
This book is intended as a study of processes of change & continuity
in a town under great stress: what it traditionally was, and how it came
under under colonial control and military occupation. See the middle paragraph
on p. 23. The army, businessmen, missionaries, tourists. IV.
WHAT IS A CULTURE & HOW DOES ANTHROPOLOGY STUDY ONE?
"Culture."
Fieldwork. Cultures are composed of symbols: that is, are meaning-lived-through.
How symbols, meanings, cultural lives are made: motivating behaviour. Cultures
as improvisations. Actor-oriented v.s. Observer-oriented perspectives.
Barrett, Richard A.
1991 "The Meaning
of Culture." From his: Culture and
Conduct: An Excursion in Anthropology.
Belmont, Calif: Wadsworth. Pp. 54-76. [23
Culture as symbol, code, communication,
improvisation, creativity.
Geertz on
the Enlightenment Concept of Culture [2
Wagner, Roy
1975 Chapter 2: "Culture
as Creativity." From his The Invention
of Culture, pp.17-34 [18
V. COMMUNICATION &
LANGUAGE, SYMBOLS & MEANINGS
Social life
is communication (including language). The nature of language & some
special qualities of symboling consciousness.
Bolinger, Dwight
1975 "Some Traits
of Language." As Reprinted in: The
Human Way (H.R. Bernard, ed.), pp. 95-101. [7
Arbitrariness, digital coding, universality.
Words mean differently than, for example, tone of voice. What we say vs.
how we say it. An old piece, but it says a lot quickly.
Koestler
& Burke on Symboling and Consciousness [1
VI. INTERLUDE ON RACE
One of the most important social catagories that
operates in North American society is that of race. It can't be ignored.
We'll briefly discuss racial & ethnic categorization, and how it's
used.
Crapo, Richley H.
2002 "Race, Racialism
and Racism". From his: Cultural
Anthropology: Understanding Ourselves and Others.
(5th edn.) Pp. 86-98 [13
Friedlander
on Being Indian in Central Mexico [2
VII. RITUAL
LIFE AND CULTURE
Zwieg, Paul
1974 "The Adventure
of Storytelling." From his: The
Adventurer: The Fate of Adventure in the Western World.
Pp. 81-96. [16
@Black Elk
on the Significance of Circles and on Ritual. [2
Examples of an integrating symbol
or image, of shamanism, & of the efficacy of ritual.
SCHIEFFELIN, E.L.
1976 Chapters 4-11.
From
his: The Sorrow of the Lonely and the Burning
of the Dancers. Pp. [160
This excellent example of contemporary
ethnography attempts to portray the "sentiments" of a people: to show how
events & experiences among a people are "brought into meaning" through
the play of symbols in social life. It therefore focuses on the way that
peoples' feelings & responses are constructed, motivated, & expressed
both in ritual and in everyday life. "Opposition scenario": the place of
reciprocity in the creation & maintenance of social ties. Giving vs
sharing. Spirit mediums, unseen realities, witches. Several levels of understanding
of the Gisaro ritual. When to be is to be related, the absence of society
is death.