Learning About Learning
Approaches to Teaching in Primary Education

1.Tansmission Orientation
Purpose: to transmit knowledge, to reinforce routine skills, product focus
Assumption: all children learn the same way, some just take a little longer
Context: whole class
Motivation: extrinsic
Teaching Strategies: expository, direct instruction, demonstration; often step-by-step;
emphasis on cognitive, verbal activities in specific subject areas; problem-
solving activities posed to reinforce routine problem-solving strategies
Teacher decides what is to be learned; how material will be presented;
how it will be learned.
Possible uses: reviewing background material
presenting an "advance organizer"
demonstrating steps of a procedure
demonstrating use of equipment
summarizing
2. Transaction Orientation
Purpose:  to acquire knowledge through posing problems, inventing strategies for
solving them, attention to both product and process
Assumption: children learn in their own unique way
Context:  a variety of cooperative groupings and individualized learning within the class
Motivation:  varies between extrinsic and intrinsic
Teaching Strategies: encouragement of questions, acceptance of approximations
provision of concrete experiences; learning through inquiry; an on-going
dialogue between students and teacher and between and among students;
learners (both teacher and students) required to explain and to reflect in a
variety of ways
Teacher is still in control of general direction of curriculum but
allows student choice and independence.
3. Transformational Orientation
Purpose:  to support the child in taking charge of his/her learning; recognition that both
product and process will change as life-long learning continues; focus on
needs and interests of learner
Assumption:  children learn in their own unique way, but need to become aware of common
interests and concerns
Context:  a variety of cooperative groupings and individualized learning in school and
in the community
Motivation:  intrinsic
Teaching Strategies:  encouragement of sense of competence and self-assessment
Teacher holds a broader view of education: holistic, integrated, connected to
real life issues such as social concerns and environmental ethics.
Material summarized from
Gough, R.L.,  & Griffiths, A.K. (1994). Science for Life. In The teaching of Science in Canadian primary and elementary
schools. (Ch. 6). Toronto, ON: Harcourt Brace 7 Co.


The Teacher's Role in Student Learning
Often the categories as defined above can make us uncomfortable. We are confused by all the labels. Moreover, we recognize ourselves at times in each of the orientations. We question ourselves and ask if there ever is a place for direct instruction. The authors of Curriculum for the Primary Years: An Integrative Approach discuss this confusion, citing classroom vignettes in which the teacher, fearful of being too directive, misses an opportunity to extend the child's understanding of both product and process.
  "Effective teachers are assumed to make decisions about what to teach and how to teach it on the basis of their observations of what children know and how children know it. They use this information to help children build on the known by challenging and supporting children's efforts to construct new information and to solve new puzzles and problems."
Wishon, P.M., Crabtree, K., & Jones, M.E. (Eds.). (1998). Curriculum for the primary years: An integrative approach.
   Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Further information for your interest:
facilitation  setting up the learning environment and organizing it for student independence
mediation  practising informed, careful and systematic observation, providing explicit
 instruction, demonstrations, models, informed, careful and systematic feedback
methods of inquiry  adapting the methods of inquiry , content knowledge and skills required in the curriculum
integrated curriclum  planning for links within subject linking to other subjects and applying to life experiences
(Standards of Practice for the Teaching Profession)



return to top